Tart Cherry Pie
Makes: 1 pie
Takes: 2 hours (1 hour thawing, 20-25 min cooking/prep, 35-40 min baking)
Ingredients
- 5 1/2 cups (about 2 lbs) tart cherries, pitted (fresh or frozen)
- 1 cup sugar, split in half (see Notes)
- 3 tbsp cornstarch
- 1 tsp lime juice (or lemon)
- 1 tsp cinnamon (ground) (see Notes)
- 3/4 tsp almond extract
- 2 pie crusts
- 1 egg (optional, for egg wash on crust)
- 1 tbsp milk (optional, for egg wash on crust)
- Turbinado / raw sugar (optional, for sprinkling on crust)
Instructions
- Put a colander or fine mesh strainer in a large mixing bowl and add the cherries and 1/2 sugar. (If you put sugar in before freezing, don’t add more!) Let the cherries sit for about an hour, stirring occasionally. A bunch of liquid will come out; probably more if using frozen cherries.
- While that’s draining, get one of the crusts into the pie dish and put it in the fridge to chill.
- Put the drained cherries into a saucepan with the lime juice and cinnamon and put it on medium-high heat.
- Take 1/2 cup of the liquid and mix it with the cornstarch and remaining 1/2 cup sugar until smooth. Add it to the cherries in the saucepan. If there’s extra liquid, just set it aside and use for other things (see Notes).
- Keep stirring the cherries until they start to bubble and thicken (once it bubbles, thickening will be quick, don’t step away!).
- Take the cherries off the heat and stir in the almond extract.
- Pour the filling into the chilled crust. Put it back in the fridge for a few minutes while you get the top crust prepped (and then you don’t burn yourself on molten filling when setting the crust on, especially if doing a lattice top).
- If doing an egg wash, whisk the egg and milk together in a bowl.
- Put the top crust on. If you are doing a mostly solid crust, be sure to cut some small holes for venting.
- If doing an egg wash, brush that on now. (If there is an egg allergy, you can use just milk or cream. If a dairy allergy, you can thin the egg with plain water.) Optionally, sprinkle with turbinado or raw sugar.
- Put the pie back in the fridge.
- Preheat the oven to 400F.
- Put the pie on a cookie sheet to catch any bubble-over and bake for 35-40 minutes.
- Cool completely on a wire rack. Do not be tempted to cut it early – it needs to fully set or you’ll get a sloppy mess.
Notes
If you are as fortunate as I am, to have a tart cherry tree, and will be freezing your own cherries, mix 1/2 cup of sugar directly into the bag before you freeze them. If you do this, do not add sugar in the thawing step!
You will also likely get far more than 1/2 cup of liquid out of them during thawing – do not be tempted to put it all back in to the filling or you will get a loose watery filling. Save that liquid for mixing with seltzer for a lovely summer cherry drink or boil and reduce to make a syrup.
For the cinnamon, I grind my own true cinnamon when possible. It’s milder, but many folks who have allergies to cassia (what gets labelled as “cinnamon” most places) can still have true cinnamon. It’s available from places like World Spice Merchants. (not affiliate link)
This recipe is based on one by Lindsay Landis (on Love & Olive Oil: Tart Cherry Pie). Hers uses lemon juice and omits cinnamon and includes a pie crust recipe. I’m a lazy person and use commercial crusts and prefer the lime/cherry combo over lemon/cherry.